I loved the first one I tried, so a year and a half ago I bought 2 bundles of the Rocky Patel Fusion Seconds in the Torpedo size. As I went through the first bundle, they didn't do it for me anymore so I have an unsealed bundle left. These are AJ Fernandez cigars, and Alex Svenson mentioned several months ago that the Fusion is out of production so they won't be coming out with any more - and I see that the Seconds are listed as $44.95 for a bundle but they're out of stock for good. Get'em while you can!

I'm on a 5 Vegas Miami kick these days, so ideally I'd get some of those in return. If you don't have any in your personal stash, CI has a 10-pack sampler for $29.99 with free shipping. I'm sure your cigar.com rep would match the price. You'd be getting an aged bundle of 15 AJ cigars for $2/stick! (And of course, a few extras would join the party)

Other brands I like are Oliva, Padron, Sol Cubana Cuban Cabinet, R&J Habana Reserve, Tatuaje, but I prefer 5VM for the time being.